“Who is the better guard dog, Doberman or Rottweiler?” This is a question often asked by homeowners who are considering which breed to purchase.
There are many differences between these two breeds that make them both excellent choices for guarding your home and family.
For example, do you want a small-medium-sized guard dog with lots of energy? The Doberman Pinscher fits this description perfectly.
Or would you prefer one, that is larger in size, with more strength and power yet still has an impressive amount of energy? Then the Rottweiler may be right for you!
Keep reading to learn about some differences between these two breeds, as well as their traits, and size so that you can determine which one is better for you.
Doberman Or Rottweiler Who Is A Better Guard Dog
When it comes to power, strength, and intimidation. Both, the Doberman and Rottweiler have these qualities.When it comes to protection, Doberman takes the winning title.
This is because, the doberman has outstanding loyalty and obedience.This makes them more trustworthy to carry on the job flawlessly. And, certainly its ability to be faster, taller, healthier, and smarter, than the Rottweiler.
Rottweiler vs Doberman Loyalty
Dobermans are more loyal, and here is why:
Certainly, both of these breeds are lovable in their own ways, but there is a difference in the way they express their loyalty.
A Doberman’s loyalty is more tailored to the individual. They may be loyal to their owner, but not care about anyone else.
A Rottweiler’s loyalty is more of a team player. They would be loyal to their owner, but also to everyone else in the family or “pack.”
Rottweilers are more protective of their family.
They are more likely to attack one person if they are getting attacked, even if that other person is someone else’s family or owner.
Dobermans are more likely to be neutral unless it is their owner getting attacked.
They will not care about others. Their loyalty is only to their owner.
So, with that been said. Dobies are more loyal then Rottweilers. Because they are only attached to their owner. Their loyalty is undeniable. As a knight to its king/queen.
And, loyalty is very important on a dog, when it comes to protecting.
Because it won’t be good if, they make friends with strangers. Or if it gets attached to other family members or friends.
Rottweiler vs Doberman Size
In short, Rottweillers are heavier, and Dobermans are taller.
Rottweilers are the second-largest dog breed in terms of mass. Measuring at a height range from 23.62 to 27.56 inches for males. And, 22 to 25 inches for females.
However, when it comes to the size and difference of Doberman Pinscher will depend on whether it is a European one or an American standard.
Both Dobermans and Rottweilers have a somewhat similar size.
Especially, when it comes to their Hight.
For example, standard Doberman Pinschers and European ones have a height range of 26-28″ putting European males on the higher side, around the 28″ Which makes it a little bit taller than the Rottweiler.
And, female Doberman is between 24-26 inches. Again, with the European ones, been on the higher side.
However, Rottweilers are significantly larger than Dobermans when it comes down to their weight.
Both male and female Rottweiler breeds, stand between 110-130 lbs.
On the other hand, Doberman Pinschers range in size from 65-90 lbs, depending on their gender and breed type.
Now that we have learned that Rotties are slightly heftier than Dobes, we can’t ignore their height differences.
Standard Doberman Pinschers tend to be long and lean, while the sturdy body of the European Dobie is similar to the rottweiler.
Given them that classic barrel shape we’ve come to love.
They also, look very different when you compare coat types: The short hair on a Doberman makes them appear sleek while their longer fur coats make Rotties seem much bulkier!
Doberman Vs Rottweiler Temperament
Dobies is a powerful, protective dog.
Who is likely to bark at strangers that are invading his guarding space.
But with that been said, it will never bite unless absolutely necessary (i.e., the stranger has a weapon). On the other hand, they are not mean, they are mostly calm and collected dogs.
This dog is classy and respectful. In no way want to be vicious or moody.
But, of course, If a Dobie, is not trained properly it could tend to think on it own. This dog has a powerful personality.
In other words, it could steal your favorite bed.
If you could describe your ideal guard dog as “aloof,” this breed would probably fit that description perfectly.
Furthermore, the devotion to its owner is unwavering. So, much that will follow you everywhere to make sure you are safe. This dog is on duty 24/7.
However, it does have a possessive streak.
So, if not train properly, you could see it barking at people, who come too close to its “food,” children who climb on it or try to hug it, etc.
It’s key important that your family understand its need for space, but also reinforce the rules of good behavior by not allowing anyone to pull on its ears, tail, or lips.
While the Rottweiler is an Independent, and intimidating breed.
And, because it is a driven and alert dog, is more likely to bite if an unfamiliar person invades its space.
If you were to describe your ideal guard dog as “protective,” this breed would probably fit that description perfectly.
It has a powerful personality. In other words, it will not think you are the boss unless trained to think that way.
The Rottweiler needs a dominant owner, who can control it with an iron hand.
So, it understands where its place is from day one in your household.
Which Is More Aggressive Rottweiler Or Doberman
In short, Rottweiler is known to be more aggressive. Due to the fact that is responsible for more human attacks than Doberman. According, to the human deaths recorded in 2005-2019.
Rottiers have a naturally high prey drive, and they tend to challenge their handler by trying to bite them.
Furthermore, rottweiler and Doberman, are breeds that are known to be aggressive.
And, although they both have been used for similar purposes, there are differences between the two.
While both breeds have high prey drives, the Doberman has a higher tolerance for pain, making it less likely to back down during a dangerous situation.
Rottweilers, on the other hand, put forth more effort and causing more damage when they do go on the offensive mode.
Both breeds are courageous, but Rottweilers have a natural tendency to be more fearless than Dobermans.
Furthermore, their type of breeding has led to some differences in their behaviors.
Which can lead to more aggression. For example, Rottweilers are bred for hunting and herding purposes. Which makes them want to be nipping.
And, although Dobermans have also been used for hunting.
They were originally bred to be guard dogs. And, while they take their job seriously they are not as aggressive as rottweilers.
Certainly, an aggressive rottweiler is more likely to lash out in anger or fear that can result in biting or other forms of aggression.
On the other hand, An aggressive Doberman is more likely to warn animals and people, away from their territory or handler.
Doberman vs Rottweiler Bite Force
Doberman Pinschers have a bite force of 320 pounds, while a Rottweiler can have up to 328 pounds.
The difference is minuscule, but the Rottweiler has an advantage of 6 more pounds of force than the Doberman.
Doberman Pinschers are known to have a strong bite force, using their chompers for various purposes.
The Rottweiler is another dog breed known for its powerful jaws, using them as a guardian and protector. Because of their difference in physical size, Rottweilers have more powerful jaws.
Doberman Pinschers use their jaws for various purposes, such as crushing objects and clamped down on an arm or leg of an intruder or other threat.
A Rottweiler uses its strong bite force in the same way but is also used for pulling carts and carrying objects.
The Rottweiler also has a tendency to clamp down on an object and not let go, continuing to bite until the threat is dead.
Doberman Or Rottweiler Better With Children
When it comes to choosing, none of them is suitable for small children. However, Doberman is a much better choice for older children than Rottweiler. Because of its unconditional obedience and loyalty.
is more famous for its friendliness, obedience, and fidelity towards its owner.
This dog breed is considered one of the most obedient breeds and it will never be mean to its family. The level of love that this dog provides is unmeasurable.
And, with that been said it is really devoted to its family and gentle with older children. If trained properly from puppyhood, Doberman is a great dog breed for older children.
However, it is a fairly big dog and is very rough when it is playing. Which can hurt small kids with its weight, If steps on them.
This dog is not aware of its big size, and it’s not careful when it runs or jumps.
So, it could knock kids down, or nibble them with its teeth if they are running around.
Dobies tend to get anxious if young children are crying, yelling, or restless.
But, Doberman will never be dangerous in any situation to their family.
Contrary to Rottweiler’s bad name, this dog breed can be obedient if trained well and socialized early.
But is not advise to live children unattended with this dog.
So, unfortunately, they can’t be trusted around children.
It is great for families with older children who will not tease or hurt them.
However, it is not a good idea to get this breed if you have young kids.
Because of their temperament and strength, they can hurt small kids.
Also, their protective nature can be harmful, if any stranger comes close to your kids.
Rottweilers are very protective of the family they live with, and they will be relentless to protect them.
This is how they were bred and it is their nature.
So, if you want to get the best of this dog breed, get Rottweilers only if you have kids who are at least 8 years old.
Doberman vs Rottweiler Health Problems
Rottweilers and Dobermans are dogs with a very similar appearance, but their difference in health is significant.
The difference in health can be attributed to their difference in genetic makeup and the difference in breeding practices over time.
So, buying the dog from a reputable breeder can decrease the risk of serious health problems.
Here you have a list of differences between Rottweiler and Doberman health problems.
Rottweiler health problems:
- Prone to obesity, which can lead to an increase of the most common diseases in this dog breed, such as:
- osteoarthritis, diabetes, and heart disease
3. they suffer from hip dysplasia [HD], which is a very common health problem in large dogs, and can lead to a lot of pain and arthritis;
4. they are also known to suffer from the following canine health problems: entropion, cruciate ligament tear, muscle injuries
5. cataracts, Wobbler syndrome [a neurological disorder], and cystinuria;
6. they are also prone to several types of cancer: mast cell tumors, osteosarcoma, and hemangiosarcoma;
7. they often develop Demodicosis.
Doberman health problems:
- Are very prone to hip dysplasia;
2. They suffer from Demodicosis as well as Rottweilers, but to a slightly lower degree;
3. They are also known to suffer from the following canine health problems: entropion, epilepsy, gastric torsion, and Von Willebrand disease;
4. Their most common type of cancer is lymphosarcoma.
Rottweilers are one of the more popular breeds, which also means that more Rottweilers face health problems.
In fact, the breed is known to have more health problems in comparison with Dobermans.
Which Is Faster Doberman Or Rottweiler
Although, they can both be very fast.
The Doberman is faster by quite a few miles. And, there is no need to be surprised, as it’s true that Dobermans are faster than Rottweilers.
Let’s check some facts about their speed.
The Rottweiler has an average speed of 20-25 mph. While the Doberman can achieve speeds up to 35-40 mph.
Unfortunately, since Rotties are heavier, it can affect their ability to run faster.
While Dobermans have more of an athletic build with strong muscles.
Allows them to move faster.
The Doberman’s speed allows it to catch faster and smaller prey.
It can outrun most people giving it an advantage over any attacker. And, its compact size makes it easier to maneuver than the larger Rottweiler.
Which Breed Is Smarter Doberman Or Rottweiler
Doberman or Rottweiler?
Both dogs are powerful, intelligent breeds that need a lot of stimulation in order to stay happy.
So, which breed is smarter, the Doberman or the Rottweiler?
The Doberman Pinscher may be the smartest of the big dog breeds.
In fact, it has been ranked as the fifth most intelligent dog by Stanley Coren, Ph.D., in his book “The Intelligence of Dogs.” The Rottweiler was ranked as the ninth most intelligent dog by Coren.
This difference in intelligence, however, doesn’t mean that one breed is more difficult to train than the other.
These dogs are very quick learners, and they can master any task given to them with just a few tries.
They also have an excellent memory, meaning they will remember their training for years to come.
Furthermore, in terms of their working intelligence, which measures their ability to perform tasks, both breeds scored very highly.
In the Working Group, they were ranked first and second, respectively.
“If you want a dog who… is highly intelligent and easy to train, for whom learning new tricks is a breeze, the Doberman Pinscher might be your best bet.
In addition to intelligence, Dobermans are also more intelligent than Rottweilers in terms of their ability to focus.
They will do anything to please their masters, and they have a strong work ethic.
Looking For Watch Dog Guides?
If you’re looking for more guard dogs resources, consider checking out our other post on guard dogs.
- Are Cane Corso Good Guard Dogs?
- Are Rottweilers Good Guard Dogs?
- Can A Guard Dog Be Neutered?
- Are Australian Shepherds Good Guard Dogs?
- Are Bull Terriers Good Guard Dogs?
Justin is a protection dog enthusiast. He has years of experience teaching and training dogs. He enjoys sharing what he’s learned. Read More